A protective wall is often specified against one question: will it stop a bullet? A second question is just as important for many facilities, and it is answered by a different test. How long will the wall, the door or the louver hold out against a person with tools who is trying to get through it? The first is a ballistic question. The second is a forced-entry question. A product that answers one has not, by that fact alone, answered the other.
This note is written for architects, engineers, specifiers, facility owners and contracting officers who write or review requirements for secure rooms, guard positions, equipment enclosures and building perimeters. It explains how forced-entry tests work, what they measure, and how to write both requirements into a specification so that neither is assumed.
What a ballistic test does not measure
UL 752, the Standard for Bullet-Resisting Equipment, and NIJ Standard-0108.01, Ballistic Resistant Protective Materials, fire defined rounds at a specimen and record whether they penetrate. They are ballistic tests. Neither sends a team with sledgehammers, pry bars or cutting tools against the specimen, and neither times how long the specimen delays a person trying to make an opening.
That matters because a forced-entry attack goes after different things. A rifle round strikes the face of a panel. A person with tools works on hinges, frame anchors, glazing stops, louver blades, joints between panels and the edge where a door meets the wall. A wall section can perform well against a round and still have a frame or a joint that gives way quickly to a pry bar. The specification has to ask both questions, and it has to ask them of the assembly, not only of the wall.
Forced-entry tests measure time
Forced-entry test methods share a basic idea. A test team attacks a specimen with a defined set of tools, and the result is the time the specimen resists before the team creates an opening large enough to pass a defined test object.
ASTM F3038, the Standard Test Method for Timed Evaluation of Forced-Entry-Resistant Systems, is one common reference. ASTM describes it as a method to evaluate the time necessary for personnel to create an opening of sufficient size, and states that it is designed to simulate a spontaneous mob using readily available hand tools. Its scope lists windows, doors, modular panels, glazings, louvers, walls, seismic joints, roofs, roof hatches, grilles and similar products. Under the method, all portions of the tested specimen must meet the test level for the specimen to receive a rating.
The U.S. Department of State standard SD-STD-01.01, Forced Entry and Ballistic Resistance of Structural Systems, is another reference used for high-security doors, windows and similar assemblies. It combines a timed forced-entry test with a ballistic test, and its forced-entry levels are expressed in minutes, with 5, 15 and 60 minute levels. A designation under it states the forced-entry time and whether ballistic resistance was also tested.
Other ASTM methods address particular elements. ASTM F2781 is a practice for testing the forced-entry resistance of security fence systems. ASTM F3561 tests the forced-entry resistance of fenestration systems after a simulated active shooter attack, which reflects the way an attacker may fire at glazing and then try to break through it.
What drives the result
ASTM F3038 identifies three factors that determine whether a forced-entry attack succeeds: the tools and devices used, the number of attackers, and the sophistication of the attack. Those three factors are the forced-entry equivalent of the round, velocity and shot pattern in a ballistic test. A time result means little unless it is read together with the team size and tool set it was achieved against.
For the same reason, a forced-entry time is not a property of a material. It belongs to the tested assembly: the panel or wall, the frame, the anchorage, the hardware and the way they were installed. Change the hinge, the anchor or the substrate the frame is fixed into, and the tested result may no longer describe what is being built.
